Bend or Machine an Aluminum Bracket?

A bracket is the most common low-volume part, and also a rare part that can be made the same shape by two processes: bend sheet or machine a block. Which is cheaper is decided by quantity and tolerance, not shape. This sets out the fork in a table and gives the design rules for each process.
Character of the Two Processes
| Sheet metal bending | CNC machining from solid | |
|---|---|---|
| Material | AL5052 (5052 aluminum) 1 to 4T | AL6061 (6061 aluminum) block |
| Stiffness | Proportional to thickness. Supplemented by adding ribs | High. Free choice of wall thickness |
| Tolerance | Bend angle ±1°, position about ±0.3 mm | ±0.1 mm, precision ±0.05 mm |
| Hole accuracy | Laser holes are insufficient for fits | Reaming and boring possible |
| Price for 1 piece | Low | High (setup and material removal) |
| Price for 50 pieces | Very low | Still high |
| Appearance | Bend lines and cut edges. Suited to powder coating | Machined surfaces. Suited to anodizing |
Decision Criteria: If Any One Applies, Use CNC
- Bearings or pins go into the holes as a press or sliding fit
- Wall thickness is 5 mm or more, or thickness varies by area
- Perpendicularity or parallelism of two faces within 0.1 mm is required
If none of the three applies, sheet metal is advantageous. Above 10 pieces the per-piece price gap widens a lot, so for most brackets sheet metal is the better choice.
Sheet Metal Bracket Design Rules
- Set the inside bend R to at least the sheet thickness. Even 5052 can crack if you draw R as 0
- Distance from the bend line to a hole is at least 2 times the thickness + R. If closer, the hole distorts
- Minimum length of a bent face (flange) is about 4 times the thickness. If shorter, the bending die may not be able to grip it
- Flat pattern length varies with the K-factor. Draw the drawing with the outer dimensions of the bent state and leave the flat pattern to the manufacturer
- Nesting several parts on the same sheet improves material efficiency, so group quantities in units of sheet size
CNC Bracket Design Rules
- Give inside corners a fillet R. A sharp square inside corner cannot be cut with an end mill (CNC Internal Corner Radius)
- Keep pocket depth within 3 times the diameter
- Avoid thin ribs (1 mm or less). They bend during cutting
- Material removed is time: if the shape removes 80% of the block, reconsider sheet metal
Surface Finish
The usual practice is powder coating for sheet metal brackets (exterior cases) and anodizing for machined brackets (corrosion resistance and appearance). Anodizing is uniform on 5052 and 6061, and hole dimensions shrink by the film thickness. For fit holes, state on the drawing whether the dimension is the dimension after finishing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can quotes for the two processes be compared with the same drawing?
Yes. With a single STEP file, calculating the quote twice with only the process changed lets you compare per-piece prices right away.
Can an L-bracket be ordered from 1 part?
Yes. Sheet metal is relatively inexpensive even when ordered from 1 part, and if there are no fit holes, the sheet metal process is recommended.
How do I choose between steel and aluminum brackets?
If light weight and corrosion resistance matter, aluminum; if strength and price come first, SS400 (mild steel, similar to ASTM A36). For welded structures, SS400 is advantageous.
Summary
If there are no fit holes, thick walls, or perpendicularity requirements, use sheet metal bending; if there are, use CNC. For sheet metal, observe R, hole distance, and flange length; for CNC, observe fillets, pocket depth, and rib thickness, and fewer drawings will come back from review before manufacturing.
Have a part to machine?
Upload a drawing to see your quote.



