Types of Heat Treatment and How to Choose

How Heat Treatment Works
Even with the same S45C (1045 carbon steel) stock, heat treatment produces completely different mechanical properties. The chemical composition does not change. What changes is the internal microstructure.
The principle comes down to two steps. Temperature austenitizes the structure, and cooling rate determines the final structure. Heated to the same temperature, steel quenched in water forms martensite, while steel cooled slowly in the furnace forms pearlite.
Hardness and Toughness Trade Off
This is the first principle to keep in mind when setting a heat treatment specification.
- Hardness — resistance to wear and indentation
- Toughness — resistance to impact loads
A part that is only quenched has maximum hardness but is highly brittle. Quenching should therefore be followed by tempering as a rule. Tempering gives up some hardness to secure toughness.
Specifying "maximum hardness" as a requirement is usually inappropriate. First determine whether the part's life is limited by wear or by impact fracture.
The Four Basic Heat Treatments
| Process | Heating | Cooling | Resulting structure | Purpose |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quenching | Above transformation point | Rapid cooling | Martensite | Secure hardness |
| Tempering | Reheat below transformation point | Air cooling | Tempered martensite | Restore toughness, relieve residual stress |
| Annealing | Above transformation point | Furnace cooling | Coarse pearlite | Soften, improve machinability |
| Normalizing | Above transformation point | Air cooling | Fine pearlite | Homogenize structure |
The heating conditions are similar and only the cooling method differs. That is the essence of heat treatment.
Quenchants and Quenching Severity
The faster the cooling, the higher the hardness, but the risk of distortion and cracking also rises.
| Medium | Quenching severity | Characteristics |
|---|---|---|
| Brine | Highest | Highest hardness, highest cracking risk |
| Water | High | Common for carbon steel |
| Oil | Medium | Low distortion, used for alloy steel |
| Air | Low | Limited to air-hardening steels (such as SKD11 (D2 tool steel)) |
S45C Quenched and Tempered (Q&T) Conditions
The typical conditions given in many vendor technical documents are as follows. These are practical reference values, not values stated in the standard itself, and they are adjusted for section size and required properties.
- Quenching — heat to about 820–860℃, then water or oil quench
- Tempering — about 550–650℃
- Core hardness after Q&T — roughly HRC 20–30
Tempering Temperature and Hardness: Consider the Steel Grade
The higher the tempering temperature, the lower the hardness and the higher the toughness. However, the attainable hardness is set first by the steel's carbon content. It is not a function of temperature alone.
| Tempering temperature | Steel group | Approx. hardness | Use |
|---|---|---|---|
| 150–200℃ | High-carbon tool steel, bearing steel (SK series, SUJ2 / C 0.8–1.0%) | HRC 58–62 | Tools, bearings |
| 350–450℃ | Spring steel | HRC 45–50 | Springs |
| 550–650℃ | Medium-carbon structural steel (S45C / C 0.45%) | HRC 20–30 | Structural parts (Q&T material) |
Important: each row assumes a different steel grade. Tempering S45C at 150–200℃ will not reach HRC 58–62. Its carbon content is too low, so even its as-quenched maximum hardness falls short of that level. Do not apply this table regardless of steel grade.
Case Hardening: Carburizing and Nitriding
Gears and shafts need a wear-resistant surface and a tough core. Through-hardening cannot satisfy both requirements at once.
| Process | Temperature range | Case depth | Distortion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carburizing | Above transformation point + quenching | 0.1–2mm or more depending on application (0.5–2.0mm range for medium to large parts) | Involves quenching, so distortion occurs |
| Nitriding | About 480–570℃ (below the transformation point of about 590℃) | Thin | No phase transformation or rapid quenching, so markedly lower than carburizing |
Carburizing is applied to low-carbon steel (such as SM20C) and involves quenching, so distortion occurs. Nitriding is performed below the transformation point with no phase transformation or rapid quenching, so distortion is markedly lower (though not zero).
For parts requiring precise tolerances, consider nitriding first.
The Material Determines Whether It Can Be Heat Treated
Not every steel can be quenched. Martensitic transformation requires sufficient carbon.
| Material | Quench hardening | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| SS400 (mild steel, similar to ASTM A36) (now SS275) | Practically not possible | KS D 3503 does not specify a carbon upper limit (only P and S, each 0.050% or less). Carbon on actual mill sheets is generally low, so hardenability is insufficient |
| S45C | Possible | Typical quenched-and-tempered steel (Q&T) |
| SKD11 | Possible | Tool steel, air hardening |
| SUS304 (304 stainless steel) / 316 | Not possible | Austenitic. Strength increases only by cold working (work hardening) |
| AL6061‑T6 (6061 aluminum) | Different principle | Precipitation hardening through solution treatment + quenching + aging. The hardening comes from the aging that follows, not from the quench itself |
A drawing that requires "HRC 50 or higher" on SS400 is not achievable. The material must be changed first. This is a specification error often found during drawing review.
Machining Sequence and Dimensions
Heat treatment changes dimensions. Thermal stress during heating and quenching causes distortion, and volume also changes with the structural change.
The standard process sequence is therefore as follows.
Rough machining → heat treatment → finish machining (grinding)
- If precision-tolerance surfaces are finished before heat treatment, heat treatment distortion pushes them out of tolerance
- After heat treatment, hardened material cannot be cut with ordinary cutting tools. Grinding or EDM is required
- So heat treat with machining allowance left, then finish by grinding
The amount of allowance depends on part size, shape, material hardenability, and the allowable distortion. There is no generalized fixed value, so consult beforehand.
Because of this added process, lead time increases when heat treatment is included.
What to Put on the Drawing
"Heat treat required" alone is not enough to proceed. At least one of the following is needed.
- Required hardness (recommended) — e.g.,
HRC 40–45. This is an inspectable form. Always specify a range. A single value cannot be met given process capability. - Process designation — e.g.,
Quench and temper (Q&T),Carburize and quench, effective case depth 0.8–1.2mm - Area of application — whole part or local. For local heat treatment, indicate the extent on the drawing
Frequently Asked Questions
Can SUS304 be hardened?
Not by quenching. Austenitic grades do not harden by heat treatment. Strength increases only through cold working, and only to a limited extent. If hardness is required, consider a martensitic grade (such as SUS420).
How much does heat treatment distort a part?
It varies widely with shape, size, and quenchant. Long, slender shapes and shapes with large thickness differences distort more. For precision parts, the rule is to leave machining allowance and grind after heat treatment.
Does higher hardness mean longer life?
It depends on operating conditions. It holds when wear dominates, but parts under impact loads fail earlier the harder they are. Define the operating conditions first.
Summary
- Heat treatment is a process in which cooling rate determines the structure
- Hardness and toughness trade off. Maximum hardness is rarely the optimal answer
- Tempering hardness tables assume a specific steel grade. Tool steel values cannot be applied to S45C
- The material determines whether heat treatment is possible. A quench requirement on SS400 or SUS304 is not achievable
- Put a hardness range on the drawing, and assume grinding after heat treatment for precision tolerances
Tell us your material and operating environment, and we can review whether heat treatment is needed and which method fits.
Have a part to machine?
Upload a drawing to see your quote.



