Helicoil vs. Insert Nut for Aluminum Threads

Tap an M4 thread in an aluminum part and loosen and tighten the bolt a few times, and the threads get pushed out. In most cases this is because the material is soft, not because of poor machining. Parts with repeated fastening need reinforced threads from the start, and there are two methods: Helicoil and insert nut. This guide covers when to use each and what to put on the drawing.
Why Tapped Aluminum Is Weak Under Repeated Fastening
Aluminum is much softer than a steel bolt. When a steel bolt is fastened into an aluminum internal thread, the aluminum always takes the load. One or two times is fine, but with repeated fastening, vibration, and over-torque combined, the threads deform plastically, the engagement becomes shallow, and clamping force is eventually lost. A tap that has been stripped once is hard to save other than by re-tapping one size larger, and sometimes the whole part is scrapped.
Helicoil: Replace the Thread with a Steel Coil
A Helicoil (wire thread insert) is a spring-shaped coil made of stainless steel. When you drill the hole with an STI tap one size larger than the original tap and wind the coil in, the surface the bolt contacts changes from aluminum to stainless steel.
- Advantages: thin walls are acceptable (small outer diameter). Also used to repair stripped taps. The coil can be replaced and reused
- Disadvantages: a dedicated tap and installation tool are required. After insertion, one more step is added to break off the coil end (tang)
- Length designation: 1D, 1.5D, 2D, multiples of the thread diameter. For aluminum, 1.5D or longer is typical
Insert Nut: Install a Steel Bushing
An insert nut is a steel or brass bushing with threads or knurling on the outside. The threaded type (including key inserts) is screwed into a pilot hole one size larger, the press-in type is pressed in with an interference fit, and the heat insert is melted into plastic with heat. For metal parts, the threaded and press-in types are mainly used.
- Advantages: stronger than a Helicoil and more resistant to vibration. Suited to places with large tensile and shear loads
- Disadvantages: the outer diameter is large, so wall thickness is needed. Hard to use at wall edges. Once pressed in, it is hard to replace
Selection Criteria
| Situation | Recommended | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Repeated fastening (covers, access doors), thin wall | Helicoil | Small outer diameter and can be restored by replacing the coil |
| Large clamping load, vibrating equipment | Threaded insert | The whole bushing takes the load |
| Repairing an already stripped tap | Helicoil | Can be saved with an STI tap one size larger |
| Plastic or 3D-printed parts | Heat insert | Because there is no metal thread to begin with |
| Parts fastened only once or twice | No reinforcement needed | Plain tap. Just secure tap depth of 1.5D or more |
How to Specify on the Drawing
- Helicoil: standard, length, and through or blind, as in "M6 Helicoil 1.5D, through". Do not write the pilot hole diameter; the shop sets it by the STI tap standard
- Insert: the manufacturer's part number or "M6 threaded insert, steel". State whether it is flush with the top surface after insertion
- For both, state quantity × location. The number of holes per part is the added labor
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I order with Helicoil installation included?
Yes. If you state the standard on the drawing, STI tap machining and insert installation are completed before delivery. It is reflected as a separate line in the quote.
Can increasing tap depth replace reinforcement?
Increasing tap depth does not increase clamping force proportionally, because load concentrates on the first few threads. Reinforcing the thread material is the practical approach.
Is 7075 more durable in threads than 6061?
Its higher hardness is an advantage, but the hardness gap with a steel bolt is still large. For repeatedly fastened areas, reinforcement is recommended even on 7075.
Summary
Aluminum internal threads are more easily damaged than the steel bolt. For repeated fastening use a Helicoil (thin walls, repair, restoration); for large loads use an insert nut. On the drawing, state the standard, length, and quantity, and leave the pilot hole to the shop.
Have a part to machine?
Upload a drawing to see your quote.



