S45C vs. SCM440 vs. SS400 (1045, 4140, A36)

S45C (1045 carbon steel), SCM440 (4140 alloy steel), and SS400 (mild steel, similar to ASTM A36) are the three steels most often written in the material field of a drawing. SS400 is a steel whose strength is guaranteed by standard, while S45C and SCM440 are steels whose chemical composition is guaranteed. Because the guaranteed items differ, weldability, heat treatability, and machining time also differ by steel. In most cases, checking two things, whether the part is welded and whether it is heat treated, settles which of the three to specify.
Standards and Guaranteed Items
SS400 is a rolled steel for general structures (JIS G3101), and the number 400 means the lower limit of tensile strength (400 N/mm²). The only chemical composition the standard sets is the upper limits for phosphorus (P) and sulfur (S). Carbon content is not specified, so heat treatment results cannot be predicted.
S45C is carbon steel for machine structural use (JIS G4051). The number 45 means an average carbon content of 0.45%, and the standard sets composition ranges such as carbon 0.42–0.48% and manganese 0.60–0.90%. Mechanical properties vary with the heat treatment condition, so what the standard guarantees is the composition. In KS the same grade is designated SM45C (KS D3752).
SCM440 is chromium‑molybdenum steel, with standards KS D 3867 and JIS G4053. It is a low-alloy steel with carbon 0.38–0.43% plus about 1% chromium and about 0.2% molybdenum, designed so that quench hardening penetrates deep into the section. It corresponds to American AISI 4140 and European 42CrMo4.
Strength, Weldability, and Supply Form
| Item | SS400 | S45C (SM45C) | SCM440 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Guaranteed by standard | Tensile and yield strength | Chemical composition | Chemical composition |
| Carbon content | Not specified | 0.42–0.48% | 0.38–0.43% + Cr, Mo |
| Strength | Tensile 400–510 MPa | Varies with heat treatment condition | Highest of the three when quenched and tempered |
| Heat treatment hardening | Hard to expect | Possible (quench and temper (Q&T), induction) | Possible, even in thick sections |
| Weldability | Good, usually welded without preheating | Preheating and postheating required | Preheating and postheating required |
| Main supply form | Plate, shapes, round bar | Mainly round bar, thick plate | Mainly round bar |
The yield strength of SS400 varies with thickness: 245 MPa or more up to 16mm, and 235 MPa or more for 16–40mm. In contrast, S45C and SCM440 have higher carbon, so welding hardens the heat-affected zone and makes cracking likely, which requires preheating and low-hydrogen electrodes. For welded structures, SS400 is therefore the better choice over the other two on this point alone.
Machinability and Machining Cost
Material unit price is generally lowest for SS400 and highest for SCM440, which contains alloying elements. Machining time is largely governed by the hardness at the time of machining.
- SS400: soft, with long continuous chips, so the surface finish tends to be rougher than S45C. Suited to structural parts
- S45C: acceptable machinability and good surface finish before heat treatment; on the AISI machinability index (B1112=100%), 1045 is rated at about 57%
- SCM440: annealed 4140 is about 66%, similar to or slightly higher than 1045, but some sources say commercial pre-hardened round bar is harder and the same index drops to the 40% range
SCM440 has a high material cost, and when cutting quenched-and-tempered stock the cutting speed is lowered and tools are changed more often, so machining cost rises as well. However, machinability figures differ among sources and should be read only as a relative comparison. Other factors that determine machining cost are covered in What Determines CNC Machining Price.
Applications and Selection Criteria
| Part | Recommended | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Brackets, frames, base plates | SS400 | Weldable, plate and shapes are easy to obtain, and no heat treatment is needed |
| Shafts, pins, keys, bushings | S45C | Round bar is easy to obtain, and the surface can be induction hardened if needed |
| High-load gears, high-strength bolt-class fasteners, thick shafts | SCM440 | High strength and toughness after Q&T, and it hardens through thick sections |
| Structures machined after welding | SS400 | S45C and SCM440 carry a heavy weld-cracking management burden |
Whether heat treatment is needed is judged by whether there are surfaces subject to wear or cyclic loading. If there are, choose S45C or higher and specify heat treatment; parts without such surfaces can often skip heat treatment. Heat treatment types are covered in Types of Heat Treatment and How to Choose, and case hardening and why SS400 does not harden are covered in Carburizing, Induction Hardening, and Nitriding.
Beware of Over-Specification
A common example of over-specification is writing S45C without a heat treatment instruction on a lightly loaded bracket or cover plate. Before heat treatment, S45C is somewhat stronger than SS400, but if the load is not enough to bend or break the part, that strength margin has nowhere to be used. Meanwhile, the material unit price goes up, and because this grade is mainly supplied as round bar, the choice of plate thickness can narrow, and welding adds a preheating step. Also, SCM440 gets its strength only after quenching and tempering, so the material and the heat treatment instruction should be written together on the drawing.
Drawing and Purchase Order Notation
- Write the standard designation in the material field. SM45C and S45C are the same grade, so either may be written
- KS D 3503 revised the general structural steel designation to be based on yield strength (such as SS275), and SS275 and SS400 have different composition and strength specifications. SS400 is still widely used in domestic distribution, so state on the drawing which designation is the basis
- If heat treatment is required, write the treatment method and hardness next to the material (e.g., SCM440, Q&T HRC ○○–○○). For how to specify it, see the quench and temper process guide
- All three steels rust, so if rust protection is needed, specify secondary processing such as plating or painting separately
Frequently Asked Questions
Are SM45C and S45C different materials?
They are the same grade. SM45C is the KS designation and S45C is the JIS designation, and the composition ranges, such as carbon 0.42–0.48%, are the same, so either may be written on the drawing.
Can SS400 be induction hardened?
It can be processed, but it barely hardens. The standard does not specify carbon content and the actual carbon content is low, so the surface hardens only slightly even after induction quenching. Details are in Carburizing, Induction Hardening, and Nitriding.
When should SCM440 be used instead of S45C?
When a thick section must be quenched and tempered through to the core, or when impact and fatigue loads are large. S45C has lower hardenability than SCM440, so thick sections are hard to harden to the core.
Summary
- SS400 is a structural steel with guaranteed strength, while S45C and SCM440 are machine structural steels with guaranteed composition
- SS400 is the baseline for welded structures and sheet brackets, S45C for shafts and pins, and SCM440 for high loads and thick sections
- Q&T SCM440 has a high material cost and requires lower cutting speeds, so machining time increases as well
- Specifying S45C or SCM440 without heat treatment on a lightly loaded part only raises material cost
On MakeIT, upload a STEP file and you can compare CNC quotes for the three steels by material.
Have a part to machine?
Upload a drawing to see your quote.



