SUS304 vs. SUS316 (304 vs. 316 Stainless)

Conclusion
The compositional difference between SUS316 (316 stainless steel) and SUS304 (304 stainless steel) is 2~3% molybdenum, and its effect is limited to pitting resistance in chloride environments. Strength is identical by specification. There is only one selection criterion: exposure to salt.
Composition Comparison
| Element | SUS304 | SUS316 | Role |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chromium (Cr) | 18.0~20.0% | 16.0~18.0% | Forms passive film |
| Nickel (Ni) | 8.0~10.5% | 10.0~14.0% | Stabilizes austenitic structure |
| Molybdenum (Mo) | — | 2.0~3.0% | Chloride pitting resistance |
| Carbon (C) | ≤ 0.08% | ≤ 0.08% | Lower is better for weld corrosion resistance |
The chromium content of 316 is actually lower. The reason 316 still has better corrosion resistance is molybdenum.
How Molybdenum Works
The corrosion resistance of stainless steel comes from the passive film that chromium forms on the surface. If damaged, this film heals itself in an environment with oxygen.
The problem is the chloride ion (Cl⁻). Chloride locally breaks down the film, and the damaged spot does not repassivate; instead, localized attack progresses there. This is called pitting.
Because pitting can penetrate the metal while the surface still looks sound, it is harder to detect and more dangerous than general corrosion. Molybdenum suppresses it by promoting re-formation of the damaged film.
PREN: A Quantitative Index of Pitting Resistance
Pitting resistance can be estimated from composition. The index widely used in industry is the PREN (Pitting Resistance Equivalent Number).
PREN = %Cr + 3.3 × %Mo + 16 × %N
Note on the coefficients: There is almost no disagreement in the literature on the molybdenum coefficient of 3.3. The nitrogen coefficient, however, appears as both 16 and 30. For austenitic grades 16 is generally applied, but many sources apply 30 for duplex grades, giving nitrogen a larger contribution. Tungsten-bearing alloys use %Cr + 3.3×(%Mo + 0.5×%W) + 16×%N.
| Grade | Typical PREN | Suitability for chloride environments |
|---|---|---|
| SUS304 | approx. 18~20 | Poor |
| SUS316 | approx. 24~28 | Good |
| Duplex 2205 | approx. 34~38 | Excellent |
Note: PREN is not a guaranteed value stated in the standard; it is an estimate calculated from actual composition. The values above are typical values within the composition ranges and vary with the mill certificate composition.
Note that the molybdenum coefficient is 3.3. Because 1% molybdenum is more than three times as effective as 1% chromium, adding just 2~3% raises PREN substantially.
Strength Is Identical by Specification
| Item | SUS304 | SUS316 | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tensile strength (min.) | 515 MPa (ASTM A240) / 520 N/mm² (JIS G4305, KS D3705) | Varies by standard | |
| Yield strength 0.2% (min.) | 205 MPa | Same in ASTM, JIS, and KS | |
| Heat-treatment hardening | Not possible | Common to austenitic grades | |
All three standards (ASTM, JIS, KS) set the same minimum values for 304 and 316 (in the solution-annealed condition). The notion that "316 is stronger" has no basis in the standards.
The reason to choose 316 is corrosion resistance, not strength. If you specified 316 for strength, the choice should be reconsidered.
Note also that the yield strength above is a value for the solution-annealed condition only. Cold-rolled material is higher and is specified as a separate grade.
Selection Criteria
| Service environment | Choice | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Indoor structures, frames | 304 | No chloride exposure |
| General kitchen, food | 304 | Low chloride concentration |
| Coastal, marine, shipboard | 316 | Direct chloride exposure |
| Chemical, pharmaceutical equipment | 316 | Chloride-containing solutions |
| Around swimming pools | 316 | Chlorine compounds |
| De-icing salt exposure | 316 | Calcium chloride |
| Medical implants | 316L | Chlorides in body fluids |
The decision converges on a single criterion: whether there is chloride exposure. If there is none, it is reasonable to use 304 and save the cost difference.
What the L Grades (304L / 316L) Are For
L stands for low carbon, and the carbon limit is capped at 0.030%.
During welding, the heat-affected zone passes through roughly 500~800℃ (some sources give 425~850℃, with the precipitation rate peaking near 650℃). In this range carbon combines with chromium to form chromium carbides, which precipitate at grain boundaries. These regions are depleted of chromium and cannot form a passive film, so localized corrosion occurs in the weld. This is called sensitization.
Lowering carbon suppresses this reaction. If the process includes welding, consider an L grade. Strength is slightly lower, however.
Why Machining Cost Rises Too
Choosing 316 raises more than the material cost. Machining time and tooling cost rise as well. Stainless steel is a typical difficult-to-machine material, for three reasons.
- Work hardening — The machined surface hardens during cutting. If the depth of cut is too small and the tool only rubs the surface, that layer hardens and the load on subsequent passes increases. So rather than "shallow, many passes," you must cut with enough depth of cut to get beneath the hardened layer.
- Low thermal conductivity — Cutting heat is not carried away by the chips and builds up at the tool edge. With aluminum the chips carry heat away, but with stainless steel they do not, so tool life is short.
- Built-up edge — Chips weld to the cutting edge, degrading surface roughness and causing dimensional variation.
As a result, cutting speed must be lowered and tool change intervals shortened. Even for the same geometry, machining time increases substantially compared with aluminum. Because of the molybdenum, 316 shows this tendency somewhat more strongly than 304.
So when switching from 304 to 316, a quote that considers only the material cost difference will come out higher than expected.
Frequently Asked Questions
304 has rusted. Is the material defective?
In most cases it is not a material defect but is due to the environment or contamination. If carbon steel tools or brushes touch the surface, iron particles remain on it and rust starts at that spot (contamination rust). Or the environment may have contained chlorides from the start, making 304 unsuitable.
Does 316 not corrode?
It does. In environments with high chloride concentration or high temperature, pitting occurs on 316 as well. For harsher environments, use duplex or super austenitic grades.
If a magnet sticks to it, is it fake?
No. 304 and 316 are non-magnetic in the solution-annealed condition, but during cold working part of the austenite transforms into strain-induced martensite, which makes the material weakly magnetic. It is normal for bent areas or machined surfaces to respond to a magnet.
I need strength. Is 304 an option?
Austenitic grades cannot be strengthened by heat treatment. If high strength is required, consider precipitation-hardening grades (SUS630 / 17-4PH) or martensitic grades.
Summary
- The difference is 2~3% molybdenum, and its effect is limited to chloride pitting resistance
- Strength is identical by specification. There is no basis for choosing 316 for strength
- The deciding factor is chloride exposure
- If the process includes welding, consider an L grade
- With 316, not only material cost but machining cost rises too
Tell us the service environment and we can review whether 304 is enough. Upload a drawing to compare quotes for the two materials.
Have a part to machine?
Upload a drawing to see your quote.



