Carburizing vs. Induction vs. Nitriding

The short answer
The first criterion for choosing a surface hardening process is neither shape nor application. It is the carbon content of the material.
- Medium-carbon steel or alloy steel with 0.4% carbon or more (S45C (1045 carbon steel), SCM440 (4140 alloy steel)) → induction hardening
- Low-carbon carburizing steel (SCM415, SCM420, SNCM220) → carburizing
- Parts already precision-machined that cannot tolerate heat distortion → nitriding
If you can't change the material, the choice usually narrows to one option. Conversely, if the material isn't chosen yet, the hardening method you want will decide the material.
Why doesn't induction hardening harden SS400?
This is the failure that comes up most often in the field. The drawing says SS400 (mild steel, similar to ASTM A36) and calls for "induction heat treatment", but when you measure hardness after treatment it has barely risen.
The cause lies in the principle of quenching. Heat steel to a high temperature and it becomes austenite; quench it rapidly and it transforms into martensite, a very hard structure. But martensite is hard because carbon is trapped inside the crystal lattice and distorts it. Without enough carbon, no matter how fast you cool, there is nothing to distort the lattice, and hardness does not rise.
The minimum carbon content at which meaningful hardening occurs is roughly 0.3% carbon. In practice, 0.4% or more is the working criterion for stable surface hardening.
- SS400: General structural rolled steel. The standard guarantees strength, but carbon content is not a primary controlled item. Its actual carbon content is also low, so it does not harden by quenching.
- S45C: At 0.42 to 0.48% carbon, it is above the threshold. In the quenched and tempered (Q&T) condition it reaches HB 220 to 300 (about HRC 22 to 33), and with surface induction hardening it can reach HRC 50 or higher.
This is where the reason carburizing exists comes from. When you want to keep the advantages of low-carbon steel (toughness, weldability, price) but need only the surface to be hard, if carbon is missing, you can add it. Carburizing diffuses carbon into the surface in a carbon atmosphere at 900℃ or higher, then quenches.
Comparing the three
| Item | Carburizing | Induction hardening | Nitriding |
|---|---|---|---|
| Principle | Diffuse carbon into the surface, then quench | Induction-heat only the surface, then quench | Diffuse nitrogen into the surface |
| Applicable materials | Low-carbon carburizing steel (SCM415, SCM420, SNCM220) | Medium-carbon steel and alloy steel with C 0.4%+ (S45C, SCM440) | Nitriding steel (SACM645), SKD61 (H13 tool steel), SCM440 |
| Process temperature | 900 to 950℃ | Surface momentarily 850 to 950℃ | 500 to 570℃ |
| Surface hardness | HRC 58 to 62 | HRC 50 to 60 | HV 600 to 1200 (varies widely by material) |
| Effective case depth | 0.2 to 2.0mm | 1 to 5mm | 0.1 to 0.6mm |
| Process time | Several hours to over ten hours | Several seconds to several minutes | 10 to 90 hours |
| Heat distortion | Large (whole-part heating + quench) | Medium (localized) | Very small (low temperature, no quench) |
| Selective hardening | Masking with anti-carburizing paint | Natural, via coil shape | Masking required |
| Post-machining | Grinding assumed | Depends on the case | Usually unnecessary |
The figures above are general ranges commonly used in industry. Nitrided surface hardness in particular depends heavily on the material: nitriding steels exceed HV 1000, while SCM440 is around HV 600 to 750. When ordering, confirm values against the treatment shop's specification sheet.
Effective case depth (CHD) — what to put on the drawing
If the drawing simply says "carburizing", every shop will give a different result. Surface hardening is a complete specification only when hardness and depth are specified together.
Items to specify:
- Surface hardness — specify in HRC or HV. Example: HRC 58 to 62
- Effective case depth — Example: 0.8 to 1.2mm
- Hardened area — full-surface or selective hardening. If selective, mark the masking extent on the drawing
- Core hardness — needed if the part sees impact loads
A frequent source of confusion here is the definition of effective case depth. It is defined as the depth from the surface to the point where a specified hardness is reached, and for carburized steel HV550 is generally the reference. It differs from the "total case depth" visible by eye or by section color, so it is safer to state on the drawing that the effective case depth is the basis.
Heat distortion — the real cost of carburizing
Carburizing heats the entire part above 900℃ and then quenches it. Distortion is unavoidable. So for parts requiring precise dimensions, the process must be designed on the premise of grinding to size after heat treatment.
Standard process sequence:
Rough machining (leave grinding allowance) → Carburizing → Grinding (finish)
There are two points in this sequence that practitioners often miss.
First, the grinding allowance must be left in advance. If you machine to final size with no allowance and then carburize, there is no way to recover the distorted dimensions. You have to make the part again.
Second, grinding removes the hardened case. If you grind 0.2mm off the surface, the case also gets 0.2mm thinner. So CHD must be specified as a value that accounts for the grinding allowance. If the drawing doesn't state whether it is "after grinding" or "as heat-treated", disputes arise.
Induction hardening heats locally, so distortion is relatively small, but not zero. Long, slender shafts can bend.
Nitriding runs at a low 500 to 570℃ with no quenching step, so it has the least distortion. The greatest practical value of nitriding is that it can be applied to parts already precision-machined. However, process time is in tens of hours, which has a large impact on lead time.
When selective hardening is needed
There are often areas that must not be hardened. Typical examples are areas that will be drilled or tapped afterward, and areas that must be welded.
- Induction hardening: Only the area touched by the coil is heated, so selective hardening is the most natural. No separate masking is needed.
- Carburizing: Manual work to apply and dry anti-carburizing paint is added. If the masking area is large or the shape is complex, labor increases.
- Nitriding: Masking is required.
What determines cost and lead time
All three processes are outsourced, batch-based processes that use a furnace. The cost structure differs from machining.
- Charged per batch — a batch cost is incurred even for small quantities. As quantity grows, the per-part cost drops quickly.
- In carburizing, depth is time — it takes several hours for carbon to penetrate 1mm. The deeper the CHD you require, the higher the cost. Do not specify deeper than necessary.
- In nitriding, process time is lead time — it is in tens of hours, so reflect it in the delivery plan early.
- Masking is manual labor — proportional to extent and shape complexity.
- Grinding after heat treatment is a separate operation — in practice the grinding cost is often larger than the heat treatment cost. When comparing quotes, check whether grinding is included.
- Added lead time — because these are outsourced processes, counting only in-house machining will cause you to underestimate the lead time.
Five common mistakes
- Specifying induction hardening on SS400 — hardness does not rise. Change the material to S45C or higher, or, if it must stay low-carbon steel, switch to carburizing steel and apply carburizing.
- Specifying carburizing with no grinding allowance — there is no way to recover the distorted dimensions.
- Giving hardness but no depth — "HRC 60" alone is not a complete specification. Each shop delivers a different depth.
- Carburizing a precision fit area — distortion takes it out of tolerance. Consider nitriding, or include grinding after heat treatment in the process.
- Not masking tapped or threaded areas — hardened threads become brittle and can break during fastening.
See also
- Carburizing heat treatment process details
- Surface Q&T (induction heat treatment) process details
- Types of Heat Treatment and How to Choose (the four through-hardening processes)
If the drawing and material are set, MakeIT can quote machining and finishing together.
Have a part to machine?
Upload a drawing to see your quote.



